How to Know if a Publisher is Reputable – Part 1

Is [insert name] publishing a good publisher?

I get this question all the time, usually from authors wanting to know if a publisher is reputable. Nowadays, the publishing environment is such that anybody can put up a website and call themselves a publishing house. As a result, there are hundreds, if not thousands, of small publishers out there who will publish your short story or novel. So how to you sift the wheat from the chaff?

road-sign-63983_640Ask yourself what you want from a publisher. Decide what your expectations are and then do some research to see if they are realistic. Ask what you will get out of the relationship. Are you paying money to get your novel published, even a little? Do they require you to do all the marketing? Is their marketing almost 100% internet based? What does their distribution look like? How transparent are their business practices?

While the answers to these questions will vary greatly from one publishing house to another, there are a few warning signs to watch for that indicate that a publisher isn’t what they appear to be.

Warning Signs

Non-disclosure Agreement

The publishing house requires that you sign a non-disclosure agreement before entering into negotiations or before issuing a contract. This indicates that the publisher has something to hide, that their business practices aren’t on the up and up, or that their royalty rates are lower than standard. This makes one question whether the publisher will hold up their end of the contract.

One-sided Contract

A lopsided contract gives most of the rights to the publisher and is of little benefit to the author. Never sign a contract thinking that the publisher is looking out for your interests. There should be a give and take to make the business venture appealing to both parties. Spending the money to have a lawyer look over the contract is money well spent if it saves you from a binding contract with little benefit to you.

Unfair Royalty Rates

Is the publishing house offering you a small royalty when they have minimal overhead? If their distribution is nonexistent or consists mostly of ebooks and shipping a few paperbacks out of someone’s garage and the author is expected to do most of the promotion, the overhead is not equal to that of a big publishing house. You should get a bigger cut if the publishing house is not bringing much in the way of services to the table. Otherwise, you may want to consider self-publishing.

Lack of References

What do current and former authors of the publishing house say about their experiences with the publisher? Is the feedback positive? Or are they even allowed to talk to you? If the only people you can talk to are agents of the publisher, you may want to look elsewhere.

Little Industry Experience

How well do they know the business of publishing? A simple search of the internet will let you know if the principles of the publishing house know their stuff. If there’s little information available, ask about their industry experience. If they give you the run around, run the other way.

Pay to Publish

If a publisher asks you to front the money to publish your book (even a small part) or uses words like partner, investor or entrepreneur when referring to their authors, they could be a vanity publisher. You will be expected to pay for some or all the cost to publish your book. Chances are you will also be responsible for the majority of your marketing. And while not every vanity publisher is bad, you should do your homework. If you are not interested in working with a vanity publisher, walk away.

Stay tuned. Tomorrow I will post Part 2 of “How to Know if a Publisher is Reputable,” which will address potential problems with marketing and a how a publisher positions their catalog of books.

Special thanks to Shay Goodman and Lauren Schmelz for their contributions to this article.

How to Know if a Publisher is Reputable – Part 2


2 comments on “How to Know if a Publisher is Reputable – Part 1

  1. This is a wonderful article full of sage advice and I’m very glad, knowing what I know now, that my gut instinct has always been to be a little suspicious of anything that comes too easy. Not that I’ve actually finished a book or anything, lol, but still.

    Best of luck to you girls, and I do hope we’ll be able to keep in touch.


    PS: The blog looks really great! Very professional, yet approachable.

    Date: Thu, 2 May 2013 13:15:49 +0000 To: c_diane@msn.com

  2. Reblogged this on L. V. Lewis and commented:
    Read this authors. It would behoove you to know what you’re getting into with a publisher.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Drew Chial

Advice for writers, stories about the world they live in.


A great WordPress.com site

The Flirty Reader by Lauren Schmelz

~Reading the squishy parts since 1996~


Improving the world one book at a time...

Carrot Ranch Literary Community

Wrangling literary arts for writers: words for people!

Serotonin Junkie

jousting with the windmills in my mind

The Red Pen of Doom

Conventional wisdom about writing is conventionally wrong.

Daphodill's Garden

Wait...are those weeds?

The Editor's Blog

Write well. Write often. Edit wisely.

Night Owl Editing Services

Providing authors with affordable full-service editing.


"Your Insight Into Social Media, News and Marketing"


Continuing a life-long love affair with books, movies, life...

Megan S. Johnston ~ Author Blog

Transition, The Chimera Hunters Series - Go into the unknown

A Beautiful Body Project

Continuing a life-long love affair with books, movies, life...

Terribly Write

Terrible Writing on the Web. And Writing Terribly Well for the Web

The Scholarly Kitchen

What’s Hot and Cooking In Scholarly Publishing


Literary Justice for All

%d bloggers like this: